LifestyleBirchbox vs. ipsy: A Comparative Review

Birchbox vs. ipsy: A Comparative Review

Birchbox VS Ipsy, which one is better? There are so many beauty subscription services out there that it can be hard to choose which one is right for you. Both Birchbox and ipsy give you full-size products but they have different ways of doing it. Let’s check these two put in details. 


Birchbox is a monthly subscription box of beauty products. The company was founded in 2010, and it has been growing steadily ever since. Birchbox has a higher price point than ipsy, but there are still some things they offer at an affordable price. Like their rewards program that makes it easy to rack up points on every purchase you make!

It’s a great subscription box for you if you like to try new products and discover new brands. Birchbox has partnered with many well-known brands—like Benefit, Tarte, and Stila. So there are always some exciting things in the box.


ipsy is a monthly beauty subscription box that sends you 4-5 samples every month. You can cancel at any time, and it’s more expensive than Birchbox ($10 per month versus $5).

You can expect to receive a mix of makeup, skincare, haircare, and fragrance samples. I’ve been a subscriber for over 2 years now and have never been disappointed with the products or the curation. You also get access to their website where you can view reviews of each sample before deciding if you want to purchase it or not. I think this is a great subscription box if you’re looking for high-end beauty products that are often hard to find in stores.

Birchbox vs Ipsy

Birchbox is a sample-based beauty subscription box. It sends you 5 deluxe samples of mostly full-sized products, and it also includes a full-sized product or two (if you are subscribed to the deluxe plan). You can cancel your subscription at any time and keep all of the products you’ve received in your box so far.

Ipsy, on the other hand, is more focused on one type of product: makeup brushes, mascaras, nail polishes etc.; but they include additional accessories like lip glosses too – all for $10 per month! The value of these items were always great but now that Birchbox has started including them as well (in their boxes), I think it’s even better!

These two beauty box companies give you samples of products, but which one is the best is up to you.

Birchbox and Ipsy are two great beauty box companies. Both give you samples of products, but which one is the best is up to you.

Ipsy has a better rewards system than Birchbox does, but both offer free shipping within the US. If you’re looking for something special this holiday season (or any other time), Ipsy might be worth it—it’ll help you get through those shopping trips without breaking your bank account or giving away too much product at once!

Ipsy is a monthly subscription service that will deliver five beauty products to your door. They focus on makeup, skincare, haircare and fragrance. Each month you’ll receive a cute bag filled with 4-5 deluxe-sized samples from brands like Benefit Cosmetics, Drunk Elephant and NYX Professional Makeup. Plus you get an additional bonus item (like a brush set or hair accessory).

What is the difference between Birchbox and Ipsy?

Birchbox vs. Ipsy: Selection

Birchbox and Ipsy both offer a large selection of brands, but there are some differences in the brands you can expect to see in each box.

The first one includes only beauty products, while Ipsy offers skincare as well. Birchbox also has more makeup options than Ipsy does (since they have more brands). The quality of these products is much higher on the sites too. For example, Birchbox will often send out samples that contain full-size product samples. Instead of just being test size or trial sizes. This means that if you’re interested in trying something new but aren’t sure if it would work for your skin type yet, you don’t have to spend any money on trying it out!

Birchbox vs. Ipsy: Value

Birchbox is more expensive than ipsy. However, if you’re looking to save money on your subscription, there are many options available. Ipsy offers three different monthly payment options: a $10 one-time fee for new subscribers or $10 per month. If you sign up for the longer plan. “Easy Pay” system makes monthly payments available with just one payment at the end of each month. Or $5/month for 12 months. And finally, their Starter Kit includes 4 products from brands like Kat Von D Beauty and Tarte Cosmetics.

One thing that sets BirchBox apart from other beauty boxes is its focus on curating great products. Rather than having them sent directly from brands themselves. Which means less wasted money being spent on products that aren’t worth it!

Birchbox vs Ipsy: Quality

Ipsy is a subscription box that sends out full-size products, while Birchbox sends out samples. This means that if you’re looking for something specific and don’t want to just try random things, Ipsy is your best bet. Birchbox also has its own makeup line. But it focuses more on makeup and beauty products than skincare. And it doesn’t offer any of those products.

Birchbox’s focus on skincare might appeal to some people because they often include special bonuses. Like masks or face wash samples in their boxes. But those bonuses aren’t always as good as the regular items included inside each box. For example: if you order one of their “Pretty” subscriptions ($10/month), then every month there will be at least two full-size items included. In addition to whatever other goodies happen along with it like stickers or nail polishes. Which can sometimes be worth more than $10 itself. In contrast, Ipsy has only ever sent me these kinds of bonuses once (in my experience). When they sent me some nude lipsticks which were very similar shades as ones they sell themselves online.”

Birchbox vs Ipsy: Convenience

Birchbox is a monthly delivery service. You receive 5 samples in your Birchbox and can choose which ones you want to keep or send back. If you love one of the products, you can purchase it online at the end of the month for $10 less than retail price. You’ll get another box with new products as well!

Ipsy is also a monthly delivery service but offers more variety than Birchbox does—and it’s cheaper too! You’ll receive 5-8 items per month that range from full size products (like makeup) to smaller samples like nail polish or hair care items. There’s no points system here though; instead, Ipsy gives each member 50% off all orders during their checkout period (which lasts about 6 weeks).

Ipsy and Birchbox have a lot in common, but there are some differences 

Birchbox and Ipsy are both subscription boxes, but they’re different in some key ways. Here’s what you need to know about each one:

  • Birchbox is a monthly beauty service that sends you a variety of products from top brands. Its main focus is on full-size products—the box includes at least one full-sized item from each brand—but it also includes smaller samples and deluxe sample sizes as well (like this month’s “Mini Box”). These can range from full sizes like face masks or body lotions up through deluxe samples like hair care products or makeup brushes.
  • Ipsy offers an ecommerce site where customers can shop directly for items before committing to their subscription; these are sent directly into your mailbox every month so there’s no need for shipping charges!

Birchbox and Ipsy cancellation policy 


If you’ve received a box, but would still like to cancel your subscription:

  • Cancel before the monthly charge is due (instructions will appear on your dashboard at checkout)
  • You will not be charged and no box will be shipped out that month (no further shipments are allowed after cancellation)


You can cancel your subscription at any time. To do this, go to your account page and click on the “cancel” button. You’ll be able to cancel through our website or via email. If you have any questions about cancelling, please contact them. 

If you choose to cancel within 48 hours of the billing date of your next scheduled bag, Birchbox will issue a credit for 50% of what was paid (up to $35).

ipsy does not offer refunds for memberships or individual items, whether purchased individually or in a kit. Cancellations must be received prior to the billing date in order to avoid being charged for the next month’s bag. Please note that it may take up to 24 hours for cancellation confirmations to be sent. Memberships cannot be reactivated once they are cancelled, so consider pausing instead – membership pauses can be set and removed at any time through your account page within 48 hours of the billing date of your next scheduled bag. Please see our FAQs for futher information!

If you’ve changed plans after placing an order with Birchbox but before receiving your first shipment, please let us know as soon as possible so we can correct this error!

You should cancel before the monthly payment is due or else you’ll have to wait for another box

Cancel before the next month’s box is delivered. If you want to cancel, there are a few ways to do so:

  • Email customer support at [email protected] (or call them at 1-866-237-7569). They’ll be able to tell you when your next Birchbox will arrive, and if it doesn’t come for some reason or another, they’ll refund your money without any questions asked!
  • Cancel over the phone by calling 1-(877)-216-4444 from 9AM – 7PM ET Monday through Friday except holidays; Sunday hours are also available by calling 1-(877)-216-4455. You can also cancel in person at any one of the locations 

Birchbox and Ipsy Reviews – which is better? 


The company’s name comes from the birch tree, which produces aromatic resin that can be used as a natural remedy for many skin conditions. Birchbox uses this same idea to deliver high-quality skincare products that are designed to treat common problems like dryness or redness.

In addition to its wide range of skincare products and accessories, Birchbox also sends out makeup samples each month with each box—and they’re usually pretty good quality! If you want something specific in your next order (like an eyebrow pencil), simply message them on Facebook or Instagram and they’ll take care of it for you within 48 hours (or sooner). Looking to boost your Instagram presence? Check out for ways to enhance your following!


Ipsy also has more unique brands than Birchbox (like Makeup Geek), which makes it worth considering if you’re looking for something new. If you’re already subscribed to Birchbox and want something different or better quality, try out ipsy instead!

Birchbox is better.

Birchbox is more cost-effective and has a wider variety of products. You get two hand-selected samples, as opposed to one in Birchbox. The second sample can be used as part of your monthly subscription or you can choose to cancel it before it gets shipped out. That’s not the case with Ipsy, where you have to wait for your first box to arrive before receiving any additional items.

If you decide that one product isn’t working for you, Birchbox will ship a replacement free of charge within 30 days—no questions asked! This is something that I’ve never had happen with Ipsy because most companies require customers return their unwanted items by mail only (or via email). If there’s no way around sending back samples from Ipsy then just ask them when they arrive whether they would still like them back; otherwise just keep using the ones that worked well enough so far.”


The answer to this question is: it depends. Both Birchbox and ipsy have their pros and cons. If you’re looking for a subscription box that gives you full size products each month, then Ipsy might be the better option. On the other hand, if you want something more affordable with smaller sample sizes instead of full sized ones then Birchbox could be your best bet.